Tabletop or Digital: The Best Way to Play RPGs

RPGs (role-playing games) have come a long way, and now we’ve got more ways than ever to dive into epic adventures. Whether you’re a seasoned game master (GM) or just getting started, you’ve probably asked yourself: tabletop or digital—which one is better?

Honestly? There’s no right answer. Digital platforms are super convenient and let you play with friends anywhere, but there’s something special about rolling real dice and gathering around a table, even more so with 3D printed scenarios and characters! So, let’s break it down, look at the pros and cons, and maybe even find a way to mix the best of both worlds.

The Magic of Tabletop RPGs: A Break from Screens and Social Media

In a world where we’re constantly connected to screens, tabletop RPGs offer a rare chance to unplug. Playing in person means no notifications interrupting the action, no temptation to scroll through social media mid-session, and no internet connection issues disrupting gameplay (what a drag). It’s an opportunity to immerse yourself fully in the world of your characters without digital distractions.

The Power of Physical Scenario

One of the biggest advantages—and the most fun—of tabletop gaming is the use of physical components. High-quality miniatures like ours, for example, bring your characters and enemies to life in a way that digital tokens often can’t. The ability to hold, move, and interact with detailed figures on a battle map adds an extra layer of pizzazz and immersion, making every encounter feel tangible and real.

Social Interaction and Shared Experience

There’s also something special about gathering around a table with friends, rolling dice, and reacting to the story in real time. The laughter, excitement, and shared moments create memories that last far beyond the campaign. For many players, the in-person experience is a crucial part of what makes RPGs so enjoyable. Plus, you don’t have to repeat yourself over and over, “can you guys hear me?”

The Appeal of Digital RPGs: Accessibility and Convenience

Let’s admit, one of the greatest advantages of digital RPGs is accessibility. Online platforms like Roll20, Foundry VTT, and Fantasy Grounds allow players to connect from anywhere in the world. No need to coordinate physical meetups—just log in and play. This is especially valuable for groups with members in different locations or with busy schedules.

It also helps people with disabilities feel part of the conversation, as you can add extensions as audio description or subtitles in a call in Google Meet or Zoom. 

Automated Rules and Tools

One of the most famous sayings among RPG players, being tabletop or digital adepts, is “I gather my friends to do math”. Features like automated dice rolling, rule enforcement, and character sheets with built-in calculations make it easier for us that can’t add all the divine smite. I’m just a social studies girl.

Besides, digital platforms simplify gameplay by handling many of the complex mechanics automatically, adding proficiencies, bonuses, etc., making it easier for both players and GMs to focus on storytelling rather than number crunching.

Expansive Virtual Battle Maps

Online RPG platforms provide dynamic battle maps with fog of war, animated effects, and instant map transitions. This allows for visually stunning encounters without the need for time-consuming setup. Plus, digital tools often include built-in sound effects and music to enhance the atmosphere.

Why Not Both? The Hybrid Approach

This is my favorite approach. While some players prefer sticking to one format, there’s a growing trend of combining the best aspects of both tabletop and digital RPGs. Here are a few ways to blend the two:

Physical Sessions with Online Tools

Even if you’re playing in person, digital tools can make things smoother. Apps and websites for character sheets, like Wanderer’s Guide for Pathfinder and initiative control as Battlemaster, can keep things organized without pulling focus away from the game.

Miniatures + Online Maps

Use digital maps for their flexibility and cool effects, but keep the physical miniatures for that extra immersion. I guess you’ve heard of the TV Map concept.  It’s a great way to make combat feel real, combining the best of both worlds.

Hybrid Sessions for Remote Players

If some players can’t make it in person, set up a camera for the table, use a virtual map for movement, and let everyone play together no matter where they are. 

Conclusion: Play Your Way

At the end of the day, whether you go tabletop or digital, the best way to play RPGs is the way that works for you. If you love rolling real dice and painting minis, go tabletop. If you prefer the convenience of playing online, go digital. And if you want the best of both worlds? Mix and match until you find what works. Democracy is a beauty.

Loot Studios can help you tell your story through highly detailed miniatures. Choose your favorite bundle from our previous releases or sign up for Fantasy or Sci-Fi to receive a new bundle every month. You can also check out some tips at our YouTube Channel.